Kind of surprised no one has started a list like this. What games do you guys like that you know you probably shouldn't like? Why do you enjoy them? Can you recognize why others don't like it?
I start with a game I played recently: Fear 3 or F3ar. Its a mediocre game, with lots of unfortunate gimmicks and not especially interesting combat..., but something about it is just fun to me. I'm still not certain as to why. I suspect part of it is that I find the gameplay to be more similar in style to the original FEAR than FEAR 2.
But enough about my horrible taste. What are your guilty pleasures?